Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Tim Rattay and A.J. Feely
CDS Boards > General Access Boards > NFL Showdown
gpngc
Why wont we see 2 QBs taken at 1 and 2...What is the QB situation in SF, Miami cant really be leaning toward Feely after this year- right?

and does Miami need a LT?
Titanpride
Miami has a lot of money tied-up in Feely... It would'nt surprise me to they select Benson ( Texas ) to rebound from the Ricky Williams drama. The unique thing about Miami is they have a good defense and a offense that if pointed in the right direction can produce. They made a great move in hiring Sadin, but as far as QB's... there is depth at that position this year in the draft ( Very small margin separting them or grade ) and they would be able to get better value out of waiting to address that position in the mid rounds.
dabears86
A QB will be taken #1, even if the niners don't take one, they will trade down with someone who will take Rodgers, or Lienart.
LoviesBears
QUOTE(dabears86 @ Jan 6 2005, 07:17 AM)
A QB will be taken #1, even if the niners don't take one, they will trade down with someone who will take Rodgers, or Lienart.

Rodgers is a bum..................a 3rd round talent at best. Lienart owns his soul.
dabears86
QUOTE(LoviesBears @ Jan 6 2005, 07:09 PM)
QUOTE(dabears86 @ Jan 6 2005, 07:17 AM)
A QB will be taken #1, even if the niners don't take one, they will trade down with someone who will take Rodgers, or Lienart.

Rodgers is a bum..................a 3rd round talent at best. Lienart owns his soul.

very good insight, I think your right.

I'll have to drop him in my rankings rolleyes.gif
LoviesBears
QUOTE(dabears86 @ Jan 6 2005, 07:59 PM)
QUOTE(LoviesBears @ Jan 6 2005, 07:09 PM)
QUOTE(dabears86 @ Jan 6 2005, 07:17 AM)
A QB will be taken #1, even if the niners don't take one, they will trade down with someone who will take Rodgers, or Lienart.

Rodgers is a bum..................a 3rd round talent at best. Lienart owns his soul.

very good insight, I think your right.

I'll have to drop him in my rankings rolleyes.gif

I knew that you'd agree 86........... tongue.gif
Titanpride
Lienart ( Still has'nt declared yet ) benifits from a great team around him... he isn't asked to win games, just not to lose them. Rodgers would be the better pro, Lienart is a product of the system... that being said, I would'nt take either one of them with the first pick. The QB position is to deep this year and the grade/margin is very slim between this years class.
sweetd20
I think Miami and/or San Fran will move down if there are any suitors for those top picks. Both have more than a few holes to fill and could use the extra picks or players. I wouldn't be surprised to see Miami try to move down the board a couple of times and land two additional 2nd rounders and a 3rd rounder.

I think they are going to go after Warner to compete against Feeley this year and draft a guy to sit and watch for a year or two. They could still land either one of the top RB's or O-linemen in the first if they move down or even get younger on defense. Then they can address the QB position in the 2nd round or even the 3rd and hope an Alex Smith, Jason Campbell, Kyle Orton, or Dan Orlovsky is still on the board.

As far as S.F. goes as great of a commodity Leinart might be they are in such cap hell that paying 1st overall QB money is going to be tough to take. Especially when a guy like Leinart isn't that mobile and would be playing behind one of the worst O-lines in the NFL. If either Leinart or Rogers ends up in San Fran I feel sorry for which ever one it is.
adavis
SF just cannot afford number 1 pick overall money, if Ive seen the figures. They traded down 2 times last year to save money and I expect them to do so again.

Miami spent a 2nd on Feely last year, so do spend another 1st on him this year logiacally dosent make sense. I really think they go RB and get that offense chirping again. That or an OL would help right away. Just think Feely is 1 of 3 guys to beat the Pats in the last 2 years!
Vick~2~Jenkins83
yeah the niners can't afford. anyways they have a pretty good qb in rattay. only problem is that he has no o-line and his wrs are all so-so.
MelKiper1
The Niners will be around $20million under the cap this year. They were hurting last year because of dead money that is now off the books. They plan on being very active in free agency and the draft.
Vick~2~Jenkins83
also another thing to back-up a reason that both these guys should be given a chance.the fact that they had no running game. SF was 30th in rushing and miami was right behind them at 31st.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2010 Invision Power Services, Inc.