QUOTE (Defender42 @ Mar 17 2009, 2:24:59 PM)

CUTLER!!!! CUTLER!!!! GET HIM NOW!!!
We should trade Chester Taylor, TJack (or Booty or Sage) and our 1st round selection for Jay Cutler and J.J. Arrington.
This way we can add a QB that can lead us to the promised land. A KR that has the intangibles to break the big one everytime and keep our depth at the RB spot.
I'm wondering just how long it would take you to eat those words should you be able to pull off such a deal. First off, your team's offense is predicated on the running game, and Chester Taylor is great insurance, and provides one heck of a RB for you to spell Peterson with when he needs a breather. Not to mention Peterson has experienced an injury already in his career, and I'm not saying it will happen, but with his upright running style he is also more prone to future injuries.
Secondly, Cutler has one of the best set of WRs in the NFL that likely had more than just a little bit to do with his success, which you don't even come close to matching.
Thirdly, many media people who really don't look, along with Cutler himself like to project him as a fearless "gunslinger" type of QB. Well, gunslinger might be an apt moniker, but fearless is far from the truth. If you really start digging into his meaningful stats a pattern begins to emerge. He is not very good on deep passes down the field, despite his vaunted arm strength (actually was easily outperformed in this category by a rag armed Philip Rivers...just had to throw that in there). He does take a lot of chances by throwing into coverages that result in a lot of interceptions, but is that him being fearless, or crumbling under pressure? With what has transpired between him and the Broncos, I'd bet it's the latter. He is fine, so long as he's ahead, and his uniform is kept clean.
Fourth, once things start going bad, he has proved to be a gunslinger alright, having no problem throwing his teammates under the bus with the best. However, in his last 3 games last year, not once did he break 80 in QB rating (which I think is overall an over-rated stat, but it's still telling in many instances).
Lastly, he was great in Shanahan's system...what makes you think he'll be nearly as good in your system. When it all comes down to it, that's probably why he wants out of Denver. He will not be the QB many thought him to be if he has to play under control and lead a long drive down the field with more runs than passes. After all, he is the gunslinger.
My point? Jeff George was an equally, if not more gifted QB a few years back, and what did he ever do? Will Cutler win you some games? Sure. Will he look awesome on some days...better perhaps than John Elway? Sure. But what's likely to happen is you'll see the other side of the coin, or persona, if you will...and see it a lot more often than you will the "awesome" side. What you'll get is the dumb throw that gets picked off in the red zone near the end of the game. The dumb throw to the wide open WR that is too far way more often than not. He has proved time and time again to be less than reliable when under pressure, and when behind. He also suffers from a serious case of diabetes, and as unfortunate as that is, it is still a fact. This disease could easily cut his career short, if not end it entirely, depending on its progression. I know this well, because in 1990, I lost a dear friend who was only 40 to this disease almost overnight when he appeared to be in prime health and with the disease under full control. So, go ahead...make your deal. Kind of like the crossroads...selling your soul to the devil is how I see it.