QUOTE (pats4life23 @ Apr 7 2009, 12:47:03 PM)

Well actually the reason Cutler was traded to the Bears was because McDaniels likes Orton you can read about that anywhere.
Neal has been injured the last 3 seasons it doesn't matter if he slightly better then Vincent. Neal shouldn't be depended on as a starter anymore. He also struggled when he played this year and was taken out in games for Billy Yates. Stephen Neal was also undrafted so I don't know why you'd bother to mention Vincent was.
You're right about Nick Kazcur though he did start a lot last season. On a line that let up 48 sacks. A lot of which came from the right side. Hence why the Patriots need to draft lineman. Because Neal and Kazcur aren't good.
Green becomes the best defensive end on the Panthers because they just traded their best defensive end. So they are downgrading the DE's no matter how you see it. So he might be better Charles Johnson doesn't mean he's good. He's also expensive for someone he only got 2.5 sacks last season.
In the end Peppers who will eventually sign the tender if he's not traded would have more impact on there season then anyone Carolina would get in this deal.
I don't know why I can't resist arguing with people. I'll need to check with my therapist on that, lol.
1. Of course McDaniels is going to be talking up Orton now that he has him after dissing Cutler and losing his franchise QB. I think he learned his lesson. McDaniels is off to a great start in Denver. I love how everybody thinks BB assistants are head coaching material. It's worked great so far with Romeo, Manchini and now McDaniels. Charley Weiss went to Notre Dame so I'll let him off the hook but that program seems to be going nowhere since his first two seasons.
2. In 2008 Neal started the season on the PUP list and was activated on Oct 20. He wasn't replaced by Yates for bad play during the season and he didn't struggle when he came back. He played great when he came back. Did you ever consider who was the QB last season for the Pats? I'll give you a hint, it wasn't Brady. Maybe the QB hanging on to the football too long had something to do with the sack numbers allowed being up last season. If you go back and read what I said you'll note that I said both players were undrafted, I was using fair comparisons. If you want to look at last 3 seasons instead of last 4 seasons as I did Neal still comes up better starting 30 to Vincent's 27 which I might add for Vincent were for THREE DIFFERENT TEAMS!!! People must love Vincent to move him so often.
Neal Season Team G GS
2008 New England Patriots 11 9
2007 New England Patriots 8 8
2006 New England Patriots 13 13
Vincent Season Team G GS
2008 Carolina Panthers 14 14
2007 Arizona Cardinals 8 1
2006 Baltimore Ravens 12 12
Let's look at the previous seasons with both Neal and Kaczur being a big part of the line.
Over the last four previous seasons
BEFORE Bradyless 2008 (2004-07), Neal has started 51 games as part of a Patriots offensive line that for the first time in franchise history has allowed fewer than 30 sacks in three straight years.
Neal contributed to a Patriots offense that set all-time NFL records with 589 points and 75 touchdowns in 2007.
In 2007, Neal was part of a Patriots offensive line that helped the team average 4.10 yards per carry, the team's highest total since 1985.
In 2006, Neal helped pave the way for the Patriots to record 1,969 rushing yards, the team's second highest total in the last 18 years.
Neal was a primary starter on an offensive line that anchored the NFL's seventh-ranked offense in both 2004 and 2005.
In 2004, Neal became a regular starter on an offensive line that paved the way for Corey Dillon to set the Patriots' single-season rushing record with 1,635 yards.
Neal was an important part of an offensive line that allowed the team to average more than four yards per carry in 2004, the first time the team had achieved that feat in 19 seasons.
In 2004, Neal was part of an offensive line that allowed just 26 sacks, the fewest by a Patriots squad in 10 years.
3. Nobody the Panthers would get back as DE will be better than Peppers. But getting Green who it's now been agreed would be their best DE as part of a bigger deal is not a bad thing. He's not really that expense when you consider all three players still cost $10MM less than they are willing to pay Peppers. Green had 14 sacks the previous two seasons which is still better than all the sacks Brayton has had in 6 years. Everyone's sack total was down for the Pats because they didn't have any corners and got no coverage sacks which before when Samuel was here was a big reason for the higher sack totals.
4. I'm not arguing that losing Peppers would be a big blow to the Panther defense. That's a given. Otherwise the Panthers wouldn't be willing to tie up over $16MM of their cap. Right now Peppers holds all the cards and he knows it. The draft is coming up and this is a big event for Peppers because this is usually when lots of trades are made. Once the draft occurs Carolina will have to wait until next draft to make a deal that involves draft picks. Once the draft is over teams start to shape their rosters and spend their caps making a deal much harder. If Peppers does what Branch did and continue to hold out into the pre-season the Panthers can either call his bluff and enter the season without him, release him or trade him. Most likely they won't want to keep this $16MM tied up for a player who won't sign so he's holding them hostage.
In the Branch case we traded him to Seattle for a future 1st. If Carolina does that they have to wait another year to get the picks wherever and how many they are and meanwhile there is no Peppers on the field. Or, they can do like we did with Samuel; agree if he signs to not tag him again allowing him to be a free agent after the season. So there are four choices. 1) trade him, 2) tell him to sign and they will not tag him again meaning they get one more season out of him then a future 3rd round comp pick, 3) he holds out the whole season and they can continue this uncertainty into next year or 4) Peppers blinks and signs the one year deal and we do this all over again next year. Of course once Pepper signs, he can be dealt but the new team would have to pick up the huge tag price of $16MM and hope they can renegotiate a longer more cap friendly deal.
Again, I'm not saying this is a great deal for Carolina but it isn't a bad deal and certain is a better deal than we got for Cassel. I haven't heard anyone else coming to the table with a better suggestion. I doubt Carolina wants to trade him to an NFC team so trading with NE makes the most sense. Also, I'm not arguing that Neal and Kaczur can't be upgraded on our roster. That's why I suggested trading them. They clear decent cap for us but they improve Carolina's team no matter how you slice it.